I’m on a writing binge in Walthamstow. It’s the only way to get on top of certain jobs, like your next poetry collection. A writing binge also involves a reading binge. The two activities tug you into a world of possibility, one feeds the other. But to keep authenticity, you need accidents.
So, between snowstorms, I head down to my local Waterstones. I’ve mentioned it before. It’s a great, lively local bookshop. I did a reading there a few years ago. It’s earliest incarnation (before Waterstone’s even existed) was where I bought my first book. That’s over fifty years ago.
I want to buy some Baudelaire. I already have plenty of Baudelaire but not with me and I have a fancy for some spleen and evil. Well, that is what I would write if I was being literary, say writing a novel where the educated main character is looking to reinforce his alienation and dysfunction. But Baudelaire is an excuse for an accident, a chance to pick another poetry collection at random and hopefully jolt my poetry universe out of its comfort zone.
I NEED AN ACCIDENT
This jolt has to be an accident. You can’t plan being derailed. Hence the subterfuge. I am aware that I am a bit like Wotan in Wagner’s Ring. I am trying to control the future by not controlling it directly. Short of being dead, it is the best I can do.
Fortunately, my local Waterstones restocks its poetry regularly, so the blind man’s buff approach to derailment usually works.
Within an hour I am leaving Waterstones with Baudelaire, a new Simon Armitage (a nod towards keeping current) and Hannah Sullivan’s, “Was It For This”. As you will have gathered, the latter was my blind pick and the real non-reason for me entering the shop.
I got back to my flat and started to read. By seven in the evening, I had finished it. This is rare. “Was It For This” is gripping. I like it. But by next day, do I still like it?
Hannah Sullivan is an accomplished writer. A writer who has put in the work, the study, the workshops, who has listened to advice. Naturally gifted, she has improved on many of her mentors, no doubt. She has plaudits a-plenty, and very infrequently does she put a foot wrong (the odd contrived adjective and a predictable penchant for obscure vocabulary aside). She is published by Faber.
PERPLEXED AT NIGHT
So, why did I wake up in the night perplexed by something that bugged me about “Was It For This”?
The first section is an awful, elegiac sequence about the Grenfell Tower tragedy.
Writing a poem about nationally significant events is, or at least was, the stuff of poetry. Our poet laureate still commemorates events of national significance. Tennyson’s “Charge of the Light Brigade”, albeit unfashionable, is an example of a poem expressing the nation’s collective horror or jingoistic naivety. Milton did as much for his Protestant faith. The First World War poets confronted the tradition head on and debunked it although there were still plenty of commemorative poems written on victory or on loss at the time of the Battle of the Somme.
Hannah Sullivan acknowledges the Grenfell enquiry as the source of much of her material. Some today might find this a bit of an intrusion but how else, short of having been there, can a poet write such a poem? I found it moving and disturbing. She does know that area of London as is clear from here writing. She obsesses over her personal geography throughout the collection. Research, digging up documents from the past that show how dreams can be betrayed by budgets, politicians and greed, is careful and extensive.
THE POEM AS MONUMENT
However, the jury’s out because poetry does not any longer have the role of commemorating momentous moments in the public imagination. Pivotal events in human history no longer produce an Illiad. Even Virgil’s Aeneid is a nod in the direction of an Homeric past. Shakespeare had already shifted creative focus to the stage for his histories and the cinema currently carries the mantle of blockbuster informant on world-changing events. So, a poem could come across as a bit of an exercise, a poet trying to be poety, an educated person with naïve expectations of his or her craft trying to prove something to herself and her educated friends (and publisher).
“Was It For This” continues to become autobiographical, moving from England to Australia, to the US then back to London. It is actually all very ordinary, written in an exact way. The product of a first-world family and education, she does what young people do and still do, at least until Western economies crumble further: get bored, rebel, study, have sex, smoke, fall in love and in line, graduate, study some more, network, get a job… very much like the generation before and since. I think I preferred the prose sections to the chopped up poety sections but I did enjoy them all and I read on eagerly.
I am a Londoner, and I also know New York, Boston and San Francisco, as well as Australia, so the author was onto a winner with me. Walking and personal geography, the space of place are things I love. I also know northwest London and readily recognise the rows of terraced suburbia that has swallowed the lives of so many families of her parents’ age. The only differences are that Hannah Sullivan is twenty-one years younger than me and she is clearly a product of a middle-class family. She has been trained, received expectations and they are not being fully realised in 2023.
MODERN-DAY DISAPPOINTMENT
The whole book is pervaded by a sense of disappointment. Just as Grenfell was a social dream tragically failed, so are the lives of dreamers brought up in post-war Britain. Hence, I guess, its title. But why? And here’s why I woke up at 4 a.m. still analysing the work. The book reveals more about the author in the final section, Happy Birthday.
I guess that a birthday is a day for a degree of self-indulgence, even self-celebration or, perhaps, self-pity. When the poet announces that from this point on in her life, she is going to move her focus from space to time, it seems overly self-conscious and a little too self-confident. I mean, you might change your mind tomorrow, right? Remember Eliot’s minute of decisions and indecisions. To plan out the remaining 41 years of your life (her derived assertion) in terms of time rather than space is a bit like handing in the plan for your project to a teacher. The teacher sniffs and says, “we’ll see.” Where’s the room for accident? Well, my impression is, the author feels that accident (apart from a car accident – she seems to drive inattentively) is no longer an option.
ME CULTURE
Suddenly, the book becomes a product of “me” culture, it is an erudite, well-written selfie. A long sequence of mathematical observations about her life and the incidence of prime numbers introduces a fatalistic tone. Her wild times in New York are behind her. She is a mother. She revisits her old home. Life is not as it was meant to be. She is a wife. Life is biological, demanding. She is looking lost.
I don’t know what she was expecting from her education, her publisher and job teaching at Oxford (as she does, according to the notes on the book jacket). Her sense of “Was It For This”, seems ungrateful, really. Less of a universal statement about the human condition and more of a confession from a person who was lucky enough to have the opportunity to dream but whose life has since disappointed. Self-indulgence is offset by self-criticism. She grinds the gears of her car, even a speech impediment shows she is not self-confident, but it is all a bit self-absorbed.
What did she expect? She is too sharp to play Wotan, trying to kid herself that she can affect the future without acting, but her dead-end is self-inflicted. As soon as the self pushes front-stage, I guess you’re doomed.
FATE OF A GENERATION
Perhaps this is the fate of the me generation. Published material is full of it today. TV is full of it. Social media is built on it. Education and self -improvement rely on its naive aspiration. People flick through screen after screen of selfies as they ride on the top deck of the bus, Fleabag is a smash hit, influencers posture and pout with attitude, people remake themselves with makeovers from head to toe, we are self-crafted, self-made, self-determining, self-obsessed and selfish. And no artist ever became successful by swimming against the current of the times.
I think this is why the collection works for me. You can’t really blame her for her book’s success. You have an option as an author: get published or get ignored. What is printed on the page has to be imprinted in the social fabric of the age, otherwise why would a publisher print it? It is going nowhere, going to lose money. The publicity material might say a work is the voice of an age or a generation or whatever but what that means is that it will strike a chord with readers and sell.
Woe betide the author “ahead of his or her time”. Consign that MS to the filing cabinet in the hope or accident that a future culture will find it an inspiration. No matter how high-minded its posture, the publishing industry is a part of the media bandwagon, it has to pay wages and make profits. It is maybe a sad observation, but today’s successful a work of art is only as great as the culture of its time.
THE EXTRAORDINARY ORDINARY
It is not for me to judge the life of an individual whom I have only met through the pages of a slim collection. I think Hannah Sullivan and I would get on fine. I recognise her as I walk down to Walthamstow market this morning, standing in the doorways of houses, her child playing-up behind her, a neighbour on the doorstep asking her a favour, asking her round for a drink later, talking about the yoga class. She is educated, affluent, has a decent job but struggles with the demands of daily life; there are not enough hours in the day. There is a real sense of “Was It For This”.
But the work of poetry stands. The author comes second whether the author’s ego likes it or not. And this work bears witness to a time, place and a culture immersed in a fixation with self and freedom that promises much more than it can realistically deliver.
THE ACCIDENT
I loved this book but I am glad I didn’t write it. This evening it is onto Baudelaire, spleen and evil. But, you may ask, did my Wotanesque subterfuge work? Was I derailed, forced to look afresh, anew?
Not in the way I had planned. As I read and reflected, I confronted another work I have in progress. The one I was planning to work on after this one, a social history poem. It has lain to one side for over a year. I thought had to wait to pick it up again once the mission I am on, this writing binge, was complete.
That’s the problem with creative writing, it’s out of your control. Hopefully. And it’s why a writer may or may not chime with the times. All the guile, craft and talent must not overwhelm the accident. It was for this I came back to Walthamstow.
